Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Journals & Periodicals: Identifying Scholarly Sources

Learn how to distinguish between the 3 major categories of information sources: scholarly, popular, and trade.

Three Types of Sources

 


Scholarly

Popular

Trade

Publisher
  • University press, non-profit scholarly society or for-profit publishing house
  • Commercial publishers
  • Professional associations, trade organizations or specialty publishers.
Publication Acceptance
  • Writers are scholars or qualified researchers
  • Scholars of equal standing (peers) or other qualified experts review each article submission before publication acceptance.
  • Peers or jury may be outside experts or an editorial review board.  Peer reviews are often "blind" - to ensure fairness, the authors names are hidden from the peer reviewers.
  • Writers often work for the magazine.
  • Acceptance based on timeliness and/or commercial appeal.
  • Editor or editorial staff decide what goes into each issue, but the publisher has final say.
  • Articles are usually reviewed by the publication's editorial staff for mistakes in grammar and spelling but some trade publications do have a version of the peer review process. 

     

Purpose & Aims of the Publication
  • To disseminate knowledge in a particular field or discipline.
  • Present original research, reports statistics.
  • In-depth analysis of topics.
  • Reviews of current literature in the field / notable books, publications, translations.
  • Aim for objectivity & balanced representation of issues.
  • Often non-profit.
  • Generally for-profit / profit driven.
  • To entertain or provide general or niche-market information & news.
  • Feature stories, interviews, reporting.
  • Generate ad revenue - sell products or services.
  • May be biased towards a particular point of view, but generally tries to appeal to as wide an audience as possible.
  • Focused on a particular industry (i.e. heavy equipment rentals industry, the hospitality industry) or a professional trade (nurse practitioners, human resource managers, etc.)
Content
  • Generally lengthy articles accompanied with bibliographies.
  • Authors(s) set out to prove or disprove a thesis.
  • Language is formal and technical; discipline specific and assumes a certain level of knowledge on the part of the reader.
  • Book reviews / motion picture / exhibition reviews are lengthy and may rival feature articles in richness of content and commentary. (Some scholarly periodicals do nothing but review other scholarly publications)
  • Content varies - Generally newsy and/or entertaining. 
  • Article length varies, but will be much shorter than an article in a scholarly publication.  Feature or cover articles or stories are interspersed with regular features or sections.
  • Book reviews / motion picture reviews / exhibition reviews.  Reviews are much shorter then reviews found in scholarly journals; Reviews are geared towards the potential consumer.
  • Language is is casual, conversational or anecdotal.  Reading level & vocabulary is typically kept at or below 12th-grade level.
  • Coverage of current industry news, developing trends, corporate news (buy-outs, mergers, expansions, etc.)
  • Although the articles found in many can be quite well-researched and substantive, these periodicals are geared towards those working in their industry - not necessarily scholars or academics studying that industry. 
  • Information may be the result of experience in the field as opposed to research data.
  • Articles are sometimes published without an author's name attached.
Sources & Documentation
  • Extensive documentation - sources are cited.
  • Bibliographies, Endnotes and/or Footnotes are provided.
  • Always a statement of responsibility - articles are signed.
  • Usually does not include documentation or citations of sources.
  • Articles or content features may or may not be signed.
  • Sources are not always formally cited, but may be included in a brief bibliography at the end of an article.
Look & Feel / Illustrations, Advertising, etc.
  • Generally a sober & serious look - plain fonts, lots of text, un-fancy layouts, more substance than style.
  • Few (if any) ads - advertising is rare.
  • Illustrations: Sometimes none, sometimes illustrated with maps, charts, graphs.
  • Look for charts and graphs in journals presenting research data; Social science journal articles may have maps, charts or other illustrations to provide context. 
  • Art / photography / media journals are the most heavily illustrated scholarly journals, providing glossy photos and high-quality color illustrations, but generally scholarly journals are less illustrated & visually-oriented than popular or substantive publications.
  • Lots of advertising - generally heavily commerical.  Ads are colorful and striking.
  • "Glossy" - very graphic - lots of photos & illustrations.
  • Limited commercial advertising for general audience, but does contain advertisements targeting others in the same field.
  • Charts and graphs may be included to support article content. 
Who's the Audience?
  • Target audience is usually discipline focused / specialized.
  • Scholars, univeristy faculty and students; specialists / professionals.
  •  General public or special interest or niche-market.
  • Practicing professionals in a particular industry or related industries.